You are currently viewing Survivor Bias

Survivor Bias

In WWII, a consideration was made to reinforce planes which had returned from missions against the Nazis in all the areas where they’d been shot. That is, until it was pointed out that those were the planes which survived. You don’t really know where the downed aircraft had been hit, so you may be wasting your energies.

This is called Survivor Bias and it applies in your hiring efforts, recruiting efforts, even in sales. Allow me to explain:

Let’s say your company has been going through a lot of turn downs, failed recruiting efforts, or an increase in people choosing to leave. The normal thing that is done is an effort to survey the remaining employees and see what you can do better. So you can see how this is asking the survivors to fix what they have already survived!

In recruiting, we often ask new candidates (and as we discuss in Client Cornucopia) new clients some version of this question: “Why me, and why now?” Why are you talking to a recruiter, why was I the recruiter you chose for this business conversation. Again, we are asking the people who have already “opted in” to explain why they opted in.

The harder question is the one you need to ask the people who have no desire to work with you. The ones who won’t engage. It is the question of why not me and why not now. We have a specific script for it in that BD program, but it always comes with two risks.

The first risk is coming off as desperate. I see you’ve chosen to not work with me as a recruiter, why not? It’s a bit needy, right? But the person you seem needy to has already chosen to not do business with you. You’ve got nothing to lose.

It’s like asking the employee who left why they left, only after they are at the new job. You aren’t trying to woo them back, or harm their career. You are gathering data to do better in the future.

Lots of companies talk about continuous improvement, and we need to recognize that means making the hard calls to people who clearly want nothing to do with you. You won’t win them back, but you will learn how to modify your message for the future.

Coaching is the best way to ensure you get through this recession. See if we’re right for each other. Learn more below

church of executive search

Jason Thibeault, acclaimed recruiter, trainer, coach, and superhero. Jason brings decades of experience in search, and is also a published author, a black belt martial artist and a former chess champ. His specialty is getting into the minds of people and unlocking the big picture and clearing the next obstacle. You’ll have so much fun with him; it won’t feel like work. 

This Post Has 2 Comments


    That makes a lot of sense! Good point.

  2. Matt Leeds

    You certainly had me hooked with the email subject line. My initial thought was, you shouldn’t go there, but like a train wreck , just had to look. Good subject matter and I enjoyed.

    Curious as to the age of those that opened.

Comments are closed.